What the Price Cannot Capture

On my way to Madrid. My first train journey through Europe. Organized boarding, a comfortable seat, and lovely scenery. Nothing more to report.

During the journey, two people seated a few rows away were discussing a negotiation. Apparently a business deal. They were speaking Spanish, obviously (?). I learned early on that understanding a language means recognizing its cadence, the placement of pauses, and changes in intonation. Every language has its own sound patterns, accompanied by gestures and conventions that vary from person to person and context to context. Often, a moment’s hesitation can tell you more about a negotiation than an extended argument.

From what I could follow, they were considering the sale of a majority stake in a company. The offer mentioned was eight million, but only five million would be paid at closing. The remaining three million would depend on future performance.

The man seemed satisfied with the valuation. The woman was more concerned about the terms.
The contrast caught my attention because it revealed two very different ways of interpreting the same offer. While one focused on the headline figure, the other was trying to determine how much of that figure could actually be realized. The distinction is hardly trivial.

In transactions of this kind, payments contingent on future performance can transfer considerable risk to the seller, particularly when the buyer takes control of budgets, investments, and the criteria used to measure results. A company can perform well commercially and still fail to meet a contractual target because of management decisions made after the acquisition.

Whoever controls the performance criteria may influence how much the other party ultimately receives. Fact. Another point under discussion was the exclusivity the buyer had requested during due diligence. Although common in such transactions, that requirement comes with a cost that isn’t immediately obvious: while one party assesses whether the acquisition makes sense, the other may be prevented from pursuing alternative offers.

Time, too, is part of the price of a negotiation.
I could tell that the woman understood this. Her concern seemed to be not merely to secure better terms, but to preserve the ability to reject unfavorable ones. It’s a distinction many businesses overlook. Someone who needs to close a deal generally negotiates differently from someone with economically viable alternatives.

There was a psychological element as well. The man repeatedly brought up the years he had devoted to building the business. Nothing new under the sun. It wasn’t difficult to see how much that company meant to him personally, although there was no way to know how far it influenced his decisions.

Years of accumulated effort can become an emotional benchmark of value. The owner begins to interpret an offer not merely as a valuation of assets, but as recognition of his competence and all the years invested.

The buyer, however, is not necessarily paying for the founder’s past. The negotiation concerns the expectation of future economic benefits. That difference accounts for some of the tension surrounding acquisitions, business succession, and the dissolution of partnerships. One party is negotiating over an asset. The other is also trying to put a price on their own history.

At a certain point, the conversation shifted away from the offer itself and toward whether the business could continue operating without being sold.
That was the most significant change I observed.

Until then, their arguments had focused on whether the offer should be accepted. Now they were asking whether the transaction was necessary at all. That question changes the entire decision-making process. It distinguishes opportunity from urgency and prevents the initial price from becoming the only frame of reference.

It also made me examine my own thinking. When I heard eight million, I had unconsciously taken that figure to be the value of the transaction. Only later did I consider the difference between the headline price, its contingent portion, and each party’s ability to influence the outcome. Even when we try to analyze a situation objectively, we may accept the first reference point presented to us without examining where it came from.

Shortly before we reached Madrid, the two began discussing alternative contractual arrangements. Their attention was no longer fixed exclusively on the amount, but on the allocation of risk and the preservation of certain management rights. The conversation ended without my learning what would become of the deal. Typical of major negotiations, isn’t it?

I found myself thinking about how many business agreements are conducted as contests of persuasion, when perhaps the more difficult task is understanding the interests each side avoids declaring. The need for liquidity, the fear of losing relevance, the desire for recognition, and the reluctance to walk away from negotiations that have already progressed can influence decisions just as much as financial forecasts.

A concession can serve different purposes, too. Sometimes it represents a rational economic exchange. At other times, it merely allows someone to preserve the feeling that they are close to completing something into which they have already invested far too much time.

The following morning, in Madrid, I returned to my notes. I remembered that in Barcelona I had observed how the absence of recognition could change a personal relationship. On the train, I had encountered something similar in the business world. A generous offer, too, can be seductive before its terms are even understood.

And perhaps there is one question many business owners should be able to answer before negotiating the price of their companies: are they assessing the value of what they’ve built, or trying to discover how much someone is willing to pay to affirm the value they place on themselves?

Because in some negotiations, the buyer has not yet acquired the company, but the seller has already compromised their independence of judgment. The fact is, not everything can be disclosed, out of respect for the company in question, whatever the circumstances. The purpose here is not tabloid exposure, but observation.


Discover more from Abraham Cezar

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.