Review: The Mandrake (Part 2)

Nearly sixteen years ago, I read Niccolò Machiavelli’s The Mandrake. At the time, I saw it chiefly as a comedy about the pursuit of power, but I had overlooked one detail: this book has more to say about human cunning than the author’s other works.

Recently, a conversation led me back to the play. Someone was seeking advice about a seemingly difficult decision, yet rejected every dissenting opinion until they found someone willing to affirm what they had intended to do all along. I realized I was not witnessing a search for clarity, but an attempt to obtain permission.

That was when I remembered Machiavelli.

Written during the Italian Renaissance, The Mandrake introduces Callimaco, a young man determined to win over Lucrezia, a virtuous woman married to Nicia, a wealthy man obsessed with having children. With the help of the cunning Ligurio, Callimaco poses as a physician and offers a remedy for the couple’s infertility: a mandrake potion that would supposedly make conception possible, but kill the first man to sleep with Lucrezia after she takes it. The proposed solution is to find a stranger willing to bear that risk. The stranger will be Callimaco himself, in disguise.

The plot could have been no more than a story of adultery. Instead, Machiavelli constructs something more intellectually unsettling: a demonstration of how private desires can enlist institutions, beliefs, and arguments until an illegitimate act takes on the appearance of a legitimate decision.

Nicia is not deceived merely because he is naive. His longing for an heir clouds his judgment. Ligurio recognizes that vulnerability and orchestrates the deception. Callimaco lends the scheme a false aura of medical authority. Friar Timoteo agrees to participate in exchange for a reward and turns transgression into a religious argument. Sostrata, Lucrezia’s mother, increases the pressure by appealing to her daughter’s well-being.

Each character supplies a different justification for the very same event.

This raises a question: how many of our convictions arise from an honest examination of reality, and how many are intellectual constructions designed to protect desires we already hold?

The most complex character is Lucrezia. At first, she resists the plan and recognizes its gravity. Yet her husband, her mother, and her confessor join forces to weaken her opposition. After discovering the deception, she decides to keep Callimaco as her lover and begins to set the terms of that relationship.

Her transformation allows for conflicting interpretations. It may represent adaptation, the recovery of some autonomy, or the adoption of the logic of those who manipulated her. None of these possibilities erases the pressure that preceded her decision. Can freedom exist when the available choices have already been arranged by other people’s interests? And to what extent can a person recognize their own desires when the arguments used to legitimize them have been supplied by others?

It is here that the play approaches the author’s political concerns.

In The Prince, Machiavelli examines the effectiveness of power and the distance between appearance and action. In Discourses on Livy, he considers the conflicts and institutions that sustain political life. In Clizia, another comedy, desire likewise sparks struggles over authority within the family. In The Mandrake, these tensions converge on a domestic scale. Nicia’s house becomes a small political territory, where everyone contests who will control decisions and what will be recognized as legitimate.

I do not believe Machiavelli is simply teaching us how to deceive. His perspective is far more troubling. He exposes the conditions under which a fraud can flourish without relying solely on the skill of the person who devises it. Deception finds support in the interests of those who ought to prevent it.

The ending brings that insight into focus. Callimaco wins Lucrezia, the friar receives his reward, and Nicia remains content, convinced that fatherhood is now within reach. The husband himself grants his wife’s lover access to his home.

During my first reading, my attention was on the person directing the manipulation. Now I find myself asking a more precise question: what if our greatest vulnerability lies not in our inability to recognize a lie, but in our ability to invent reasons why we need not recognize it?

How many Nicias still mistake the truth for what they want to hear? How many Callimacos present themselves as the solution while exploiting someone else’s vulnerability? How many Ligurios understand that controlling a decision requires less force than knowing the desire of the person making it? How many Friar Timoteos still lend their authority to whatever serves their interests?

And how many Lucrezias, surrounded by seemingly legitimate arguments, end up calling it a choice when others have carefully made it inevitable?

Perhaps the most uncomfortable question is another: when we consider ourselves perceptive enough to recognize manipulation, are we merely offering it a more sophisticated way in?

In the final scene, the door remains open.
The key was handed over by the one who was deceived.


Discover more from Abraham Cezar

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.